Do the three hop

Archive You're reading an older Hightower Lowdown article. Jim's still writing — twice a week on Substack.

To see how easy it is for millions of innocent citizens to get caught up in NSA’s vast electronic web, consider the “Three HOP Analysis.” It’s a dance of search-and-seizure that begins with NSA’s know-all metadata computers spewing out all the phone numbers that a suspect has called during, say, the last three years, plus the phone numbers of people who called the suspect. Then comes Hop One: Agents take the suspect’s call list and spin out every one of the calls to and from each of those phones. Hop Two: They grab each of the thousands of phone numbers generated by this level-two list and twirl out all of the calls to and from those people. Hop Three: They snatch the numbers from this third-level list and whirl out all of the phone calls made to and from them. Thus, from one lone suspect, they’ve been able to hop-hop-hop through the personal records of roughly 2,500,000 Americans who are not even suspects.

 

Keep reading Jim
Get the free Lowdown
Jim's twice-weekly commentaries delivered free to your inbox. No credit card, no catch.
No credit card. Unsubscribe anytime.
Go deeper
Get everything Jim's got
Live Q&As, the Chat & Chew series, radio archives, and more. Less than a cup of coffee a month.
Subscribe for $40/year
Special rate for original Lowdown readers
Regular price: $50/year
Jim Hightower's Lowdown
The Lowdown moved —
Jim didn't stop writing.

Get Jim's commentaries delivered every Tuesday and Thursday — free, to your inbox. Join 50,000+ readers.

Get the free Lowdown →
or go paid
Subscribe for $40/year
Special rate for original Lowdown readers — regular price $50/yr